Now
31°C · Overcast
Today
31° / 18°
Sun
07:19 – 20:04
Moon
Waning Crescent · solunar good
Fishing around Indianapolis
AI field guide · refreshed weeklyFall Fishing Around Indianapolis: September
What's biting
Largemouth Bass
Where: Shallow weed beds and structure in reservoirs like Geist and Morse; creek channels in the White River system.
Early fall means bass are feeding hard before cooler water sets in. Work topwater lures and soft plastics around submerged timber and aquatic vegetation; fish dawn and dusk when water temps drop below 27°C (80°F).
Caution: Catch-and-release recommended to maintain population; handle with wet hands.
Bluegill & Sunfish
Where: Pond margins, shallow bays, and dock pilings throughout the White River drainage and small lakes.
Peak feeding in early fall. Small jigs, crickets, and waxworms work reliably; fish 0.5–2 m (2–6 ft) deep near vegetation.
Channel Catfish
Where: Deep holes and current breaks in the White River, Eel River, and larger reservoirs.
Nocturnal feeders; use chicken liver, cut shad, or stink baits on the bottom after sunset. Fish the deeper pools where current slows.
Crappie (Black & White)
Where: Brush piles, fallen trees, and dock structure in lakes and reservoirs; creek channels.
September is excellent for crappie. Vertical jigging with small minnows or jigs in 2–4 m (6–12 ft) of water yields consistent results, especially at dawn.
Walleye
Where: Deeper structure and rocky areas in Geist Reservoir and larger impoundments; river ledges.
Low-light periods (dawn, dusk, overcast) are prime. Live shiners or small crankbaits near drop-offs in 3–6 m (10–20 ft) of water.
Best times
Early morning (06:00–09:00) and evening (18:00–21:00) while water remains warm; overcast days and the period after the rain on 10 September will trigger feeding. Night fishing for catfish is productive.
Waters to try
- Geist Reservoir, Morse Reservoir, Eagle Creek Reservoir, White River (main stem and tributaries), Eel River, Fall Creek, Pleasant Run Creek.
Regulations
Indiana DNR Fish & Wildlife sets all season dates, creel limits, and size restrictions. Check https://www.in.gov/dnr/fish-and-wildlife/fishing/ before fishing to confirm current regulations for your target species and water body. A valid Indiana fishing license is required.
Indiana DNR Fish & Wildlife ↗The fishing note for Indianapolis, every week
One email, Sunday evening. Unsubscribe anytime.